Taxation logo taxation mission text

Since 1927 the leading authority on tax law, practice and administration

Unlawful curtailment

16 January 2015
Categories: Comment & Analysis , Tax cases , Admin , Europe , International

UK v European Commission (Case C-640/13), Court of Justice of the EU

The European Commission brought an action against the UK, claiming FA 2007, s 107, “limitation period in old actions for mistake of law relating to direct tax”, was incompatible with European Union law.

The Court of Justice of the EU said s 107 curtailed the right of taxpayers to reclaim wrongly charged tax. It was “incompatible, not just with the principle of effectiveness, but also with the principle of the protection of legitimate expectations of taxpayers, so far as concerns the obligation under EU law to guarantee taxpayers the right to a refund of taxes paid in breach of that law”.

back to top icon